NAS 2 — Inventories
Inventories under NAS 2 — cost, net realisable value, FIFO vs weighted average, write-downs and reversals, with a full worked example.
Read the note →The complete study post: why paying people in shares is still an expense, how to measure it at fair value, and how vesting, forfeitures, repricing and cash-settled plans change the answer. With worked journals, charts and exam traps — written for students in Nepal.
Companies pay directors, employees and suppliers not only in cash but in shares, share options and cash linked to the share price — ESOPs for bank staff, sweat-equity shares for founders, shares issued to a consultant instead of a fee. Before NFRS 2 many entities recorded nothing when they granted options: no cash left the bank, so no expense appeared, profit was overstated, and two identical companies — one paying salary in cash, one in options — looked completely different.
NFRS 2 fixes that with one sentence you should memorise:
Everyday Nepali examples: a commercial bank granting share options to its CEO under an ESOP approved by NRB and the AGM; a hydropower company issuing shares to a contractor for construction services; a startup issuing shares to its software team; a listed company paying its non-executive directors partly in shares. All fall inside NFRS 2.
Objective (Para 1): to specify the financial reporting by an entity when it undertakes a share-based payment transaction — so the effects are reflected in profit or loss and the statement of financial position, including expenses for transactions in which share options are granted to employees.
| Transaction | Why it is in NFRS 2 |
|---|---|
| Equity-settled: entity receives goods/services for its own equity instruments (shares, options, warrants) | Classic ESOP; shares to suppliers |
| Cash-settled: entity incurs a liability to transfer cash (or other assets) based on the price/value of its equity instruments | Share Appreciation Rights (SARs), phantom shares |
| Choice: either the entity or the counterparty can choose equity or cash settlement | Paras 34–43 — see Chapter 9 |
| Transactions with employees and non-employees (suppliers, consultants) | NFRS 2 is not an “employee-only” standard |
| Group transactions — parent grants its shares to subsidiary’s employees | Paras 43A–43D — see Chapter 11 |
| Excluded | Dealt with instead by |
|---|---|
| Shares issued in a business combination (consideration transferred) — except shares granted to acquiree’s employees for future service | NFRS 3 Business Combinations |
| Transactions within NFRS 9 scope — e.g. financial instruments, contracts to buy/sell non-financial items in NFRS 9’s scope | NFRS 9 / NAS 32 |
| Share-based payment settled by another group entity / shareholder on the entity’s behalf — not excluded; expressly included since the group amendments | NFRS 2 group rules |
| Employee benefits that are not share-based (salaries, bonus in fixed cash, gratuity) | NAS 19 Employee Benefits |
| Term | Meaning in plain English |
|---|---|
| Share-based payment transaction | Entity receives goods/services and pays with equity instruments, or incurs a liability based on equity prices. |
| Grant date | Date entity and counterparty agree to the arrangement — both understand the terms. If approval (e.g. AGM / board) is required, grant date is when approval is obtained. |
| Vesting conditions | Conditions that decide whether the counterparty becomes entitled: service and performance conditions only (Para 19, App A). |
| Vesting period | Period over which all specified vesting conditions are to be satisfied. |
| Fair value | Amount for which an asset could be exchanged / liability settled between knowledgeable, willing parties at arm’s length (NFRS 2’s own definition, aligned to NFRS 13 in practice). |
| Intrinsic value | Share price − exercise price (if positive). Used only in the rare case fair value cannot be reliably estimated. |
| Reload feature / reload option | Automatic grant of additional options whenever previously granted options are exercised using shares to pay the exercise price. |
| Market condition | Performance condition tied to market price/value of equity — e.g. achieve share price of Rs. 800, or TSR vs index. |
| Non-vesting condition | Any other condition that is neither service nor performance — e.g. employee must save monthly, or keep holding shares during vesting. |
Pays in shares / options.
Credit: Equity (SBP reserve).
Measured: once, at grant-date fair value. Never remeasured for share-price moves.
Pays cash based on share price (SARs).
Credit: Liability.
Remeasured to fair value at every reporting date and at settlement — changes go to P&L.
Counterparty chooses → compound instrument (liability + equity components). Entity chooses → classify by whether a present obligation to pay cash exists.
Employee services are hard to price directly, so NFRS 2 uses an indirect measure: measure the equity instruments granted at their fair value at grant date. That number is then locked in — later share-price rises or falls are ignored.
There is a rebuttable presumption that the fair value of goods/services received can be measured reliably — so measure directly, at the fair value of the goods/services on the date received. Only if that presumption is rebutted (rare) do you use the fair value of the equity given.
If fair value genuinely cannot be estimated reliably (extremely rare; e.g. unlisted start-up options with no observable inputs), use intrinsic value, remeasured at each reporting date until settlement. Disclose why. Examiners ask this as a one-mark MCQ — remember it exists, but it is almost never the main answer.
| Condition type | In grant-date fair value? | Effect on number expected to vest? |
|---|---|---|
| Service condition Stay 3 years |
No | Yes — estimate leavers; revise each year; true-up at vesting date so total = instruments that actually vested × grant FV. |
| Non-market performance Profit +20%, EPS target, sales target |
No | Yes — revise estimate of outcome each year (e.g. graded vesting tranches). |
| Market performance Share price Rs. 800; TSR ranking |
Yes — built into option-pricing model (e.g. Monte Carlo) | No — never revise. If service is completed, expense is recognised in full even if the share-price target is missed. |
| Non-vesting condition Save monthly; hold shares |
Yes — reflected in fair value | No — but if the entity/counterparty can choose and fails it, treat as cancellation (accelerate). |
If options vest in tranches (e.g. ⅓ each year for 3 years), NFRS 2 treats each tranche as a separate grant with its own vesting period — producing a front-loaded expense pattern (highest charge in Year 1). US GAAP allows straight-line; NFRS does not.
Share price is observable for listed shares. Options are not traded, so fair value comes from an option-pricing model — Black–Scholes–Merton or a binomial model (Monte Carlo for market conditions). NFRS 2 (App B) lists the minimum inputs:
Cash-settled (Paras 30–33): recognise the services and a liability at fair value, then remeasure the liability at every reporting date and at settlement, with all fair-value changes in profit or loss. Unlike equity-settled, the total cost is not fixed — it ends up equal to the cash actually paid.
| Who chooses? | Treatment |
|---|---|
| Counterparty (e.g. employee can take cash or shares) | Compound instrument: measure liability component first (fair value of cash alternative), equity component = residual (total FV − liability FV). Liability remeasured; equity fixed at grant date. |
| Entity | If a present obligation to settle in cash exists (past practice, stated policy, cash is the only realistic option) → cash-settled. Otherwise → equity-settled. If the entity then chooses cash anyway, the payment is treated as a repurchase of equity (debit equity). |
| Net-share / tax withholding | Withholding shares to pay the employee’s tax does not make the award cash-settled — whole award stays equity-settled if it would be equity-settled without the net-settlement clause (2016 amendment, Paras 33E–33H). |
| Event | Accounting — never reduce the original charge |
|---|---|
| Modification that increases FV (repricing options down, adding shares, shortening vesting) | Recognise the incremental fair value (FV after − FV before, both at modification date) over the remaining vesting period (or immediately if already vested) — in addition to the original grant-date charge. |
| Modification that decreases FV / is not beneficial | Ignore it for expense purposes — keep recognising the original grant-date fair value as if the change never happened. No “saving” is ever booked. |
| Change in non-market vesting outcome via modification | Apply the vesting-condition rules: account for the modified (more favourable) condition. |
| Cancellation / settlement during vesting (by entity or counterparty, incl. failure of a non-vesting condition either side can choose) | Accelerate: recognise immediately the amount that would have been recognised over the rest of vesting. Any payment on cancellation up to the FV of the instruments is an equity repurchase (debit equity); any excess is an expense. |
| Failure of a service / non-market condition (employee leaves) | Not a cancellation — it is a forfeiture: reverse via the true-up so cumulative expense for that person becomes zero. |
| Replacement award identified as a replacement for a cancelled award | Treat as a modification: incremental FV = FV of replacement − net FV of cancelled award at replacement date. |
On 1 Shrawan 2081, Himal Traders Ltd grants 1,000 options to each of 50 employees (50,000 options). Exercise price Rs. 200. Options vest after 3 years’ service. Grant-date fair value = Rs. 60 per option. Estimates: Year 1 — 10% will leave over 3 years; Year 2 — revised to 12% total; Actual — 6 employees left in total, so 44 employees vest.
| Year | Calculation (cumulative) | Cumulative Rs. | Charge for year Rs. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 50 × 90% × 1,000 × Rs. 60 × 1/3 | 9,00,000 | 9,00,000 |
| Year 2 | 50 × 88% × 1,000 × Rs. 60 × 2/3 | 17,60,000 | 8,60,000 |
| Year 3 (actual) | 44 × 1,000 × Rs. 60 | 26,40,000 | 8,80,000 |
On exercise (say all 44,000 options exercised at Rs. 200):
Bank (44,000 × 200) Dr. 88,00,000
SBP reserve Dr. 26,40,000
To Share capital (44,000 × Rs. 100 par) 44,00,000
To Share premium (balancing figure) 70,40,000
Par value Rs. 100 assumed for illustration. If options had expired unexercised, the Rs. 26.40 lakh reserve would move within equity only — never back through profit or loss.
On 1 Shrawan 2081 the company grants 10,000 SARs vesting after 2 years. Fair value per SAR: end of Year 1 = Rs. 45, end of Year 2 (vesting/settlement) = Rs. 52. All SARs vest and are paid in cash.
| Year | Liability (cumulative) | P&L charge Rs. |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 10,000 × 45 × 1/2 = Rs. 2,25,000 | 2,25,000 |
| Year 2 | 10,000 × 52 = Rs. 5,20,000 | 2,95,000 |
Options were granted with FV Rs. 60. After a share-price fall, the exercise price is cut mid-vesting; FV immediately before modification = Rs. 35, immediately after = Rs. 48. Incremental FV = 48 − 35 = Rs. 13 per option. The company continues the original Rs. 60 charge over the original vesting period plus Rs. 13 over the remaining vesting period. Total recognised if the employee stays = Rs. 73 per option. Had FV fallen instead, the Rs. 60 charge would continue unchanged — decreases are ignored.
NFRS 2 has no special line-item rule (expense sits in employee benefits / relevant cost line; reserve within equity; SAR obligation as a liability) — the weight is in disclosure. An entity must disclose:
| NFRS 2 vs old practice | Before NFRS | Under NFRS 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Options granted | Often no entry at all | Expense over vesting at grant-date FV |
| SARs | Expense only when paid | Liability accrued & remeasured each year |
| Repricing | Ignored | Incremental FV expensed additionally |
| Disclosure | Minimal | Full roll-forward + model inputs (Paras 44–52) |
| # | Trap | Correct treatment |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Remeasuring equity-settled options when share price changes | Never. Grant-date FV is locked. |
| 2 | Adjusting expense when a market condition is missed | No adjustment if service completed — expense stands. |
| 3 | Building a non-market target (EPS) into fair value | No — adjust the expected number vesting instead. |
| 4 | Reversing expense when vested options expire unexercised | Prohibited — transfer within equity only. |
| 5 | Booking a “saving” when a modification reduces FV | Ignore decreases; original charge continues. |
| 6 | Treating an employee leaving as a cancellation | It is forfeiture — cumulative expense → zero via true-up. Cancellation accelerates instead. |
| 7 | Straight-lining graded vesting | Each tranche = separate award (front-loaded). |
| 8 | Using direct FV of services for employee awards | Employees = indirect (equity FV). Direct FV is for suppliers (rebuttable presumption). |
| 9 | Forgetting SAR liability remeasurement gains | Cash-settled: falls in FV are P&L credits. |
| 10 | Putting acquisition-date employee shares wholly in NFRS 3 consideration | Split: pre-combination service → consideration; post-combination service → NFRS 2 expense. |
Yes. The company consumed employee services and paid with equity value instead of cash. NFRS 2 measures that consumption at grant-date fair value — exactly as a cash salary would be expensed.
For equity-settled: no, it stays at grant-date fair value. For cash-settled SARs: yes — the liability is remeasured, so the total expense follows the price until cash is paid.
Yes. Fair value is estimated using valuation techniques (recent transactions, multiples, DCF of the shares). “No market price” is not an exemption — intrinsic value is only a last resort when FV truly cannot be estimated reliably.
To a separate component of equity — commonly called the share-based payment reserve — which moves to share capital/premium on exercise, or within equity on expiry.
Answers are checked in your browser only — nothing is saved or sent anywhere.
NFRS 2 Share-based Payment (ASB Nepal / ICAN, converged with IFRS 2), especially Paras 1–52 and Appendices A–B; NFRS 3 for the business-combination scope split; NAS 19 for non-share-based employee benefits; NFRS for SMEs Section 26 for the SME version. This is a study summary — always confirm exam answers against the current standard text and ICAN’s latest pronouncements.
Companion notes in this set: NFRS 1 — First-time Adoption and NAS 2 — Inventories (separate file, as requested).
var Q=[ {q:"1. An equity-settled option has a grant-date FV of Rs. 60. The share price later halves. The expense is:",o:["Recalculated at the lower FV","Unchanged — still based on Rs. 60","Reversed through P&L"],a:1,e:"Grant-date FV is locked for equity-settled awards."}, {q:"2. Employees complete 3 years' service but the share-price (market) target is missed. Expense?",o:["Zero — reverse everything","Recognised in full","Deferred until target is met"],a:1,e:"Market conditions are priced into FV and never trued-up."}, {q:"3. A SAR liability's fair value falls during the year. The movement is:",o:["Ignored until settlement","A credit (gain) in profit or loss","Taken to equity"],a:1,e:"Cash-settled liabilities are remeasured both ways through P&L."}, {q:"4. The board reprices options so their FV falls. Accounting?",o:["Book the saving as income","Reduce future expense","Ignore the decrease; original charge continues"],a:2,e:"Non-beneficial modifications are ignored."}, {q:"5. An employee leaves before vesting (service condition failed). Cumulative expense for that employee becomes:",o:["Fully accelerated","Zero — reversed by true-up","Kept at amount recognised to date"],a:1,e:"Forfeiture is not cancellation: true-up to actual vesting = zero."} ]; var box=document.getElementById('quizBox'),picked={}; Q.forEach(function(item,qi){ var d=document.createElement('div');d.className='quiz-q'; var h=document.createElement('p');h.innerHTML=''+item.q+'';d.appendChild(h); item.o.forEach(function(opt,oi){ var b=document.createElement('button');b.type='button';b.textContent=opt; b.addEventListener('click',function(){ picked[qi]=oi; d.querySelectorAll('button').forEach(function(x){x.classList.remove('correct','wrong')}); b.classList.add(oi===item.a?'correct':'wrong'); if(oi!==item.a){d.querySelectorAll('button')[item.a].classList.add('correct');} var ex=d.querySelector('.exp'); if(ex) ex.textContent=item.e; }); d.appendChild(b); }); var ex=document.createElement('p');ex.className='exp';ex.style.cssText='font-size:.9rem;color:var(--muted)';d.appendChild(ex); box.appendChild(d); }); document.getElementById('scoreBtn').addEventListener('click',function(){ var s=0; Q.forEach(function(item,qi){ if(picked[qi]===item.a) s++; }); document.getElementById('scoreOut').textContent='You scored '+s+' / '+Q.length+(s===Q.length?' — NFRS 2 vesting rules mastered.':' — re-read Chapters 7 and 10, then try again.'); });